← All comparisons

HaulierMagic vs spreadsheets

Spreadsheets and a whiteboard are where most operators start. They are free, but you pay for them in Sunday-night invoicing, vanished PODs and a plan only you can see. Here is what changes when you move to one connected system.

Book a demo See the full comparison

Side by side

An honest look at both.

Where most start

Spreadsheets and whiteboards

  • Free, flexible and familiar to everyone in the office.
  • Every job is entered by hand, and often re-entered for routing and for invoicing.
  • No live tracking, so planners and customers ring the driver for updates.
  • No driver app, ePOD or audit trail to lean on for compliance.
  • Hard to see the whole day at once, and easy to slip under pressure.
The modern all-in-one

HaulierMagic

  • One system where each job is entered once, then flows to planning, the driver, tracking and the invoice.
  • Live tracking and ETAs, with a customer portal so people stop ringing the office.
  • Driver app with ePOD, plus DVSA walkaround checks and a full audit trail.
  • HGV-safe routing built in, and invoicing that syncs with Xero.
  • One live view of the day that the whole team can see.
  • Simple to start, with checks, ePOD, tracking and invoicing all included rather than charged as extras.
  • As flexible as a spreadsheet, but structured: shape the workflows, stages and rules around how you already work, and keep the audit trail.

Which is right for you

There is no single right answer.

Both are capable. It comes down to how you run, and what you want to spend your time on.

Stay on spreadsheets if

  • You run only a handful of jobs a week.
  • Cost is the single deciding factor right now.
  • You do not yet need a compliance trail or customer updates.

Move to HaulierMagic if

  • You are losing time to rekeying and chasing updates by phone.
  • You need a clear compliance and proof-of-delivery trail.
  • You want to grow without piling on more admin.
  • You have worried a new system would be complicated, and want one that starts simple and is quick to learn.
  • You want to keep the way you work, with the system shaped around your process.

Get off the spreadsheets.

Book a 30-minute demo and see your whole operation on one board.

Book a demo